Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Gunnar Miller's avatar

I used to get a chafed that at the very minute much of the world observes a solemn moment of reflection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Remembrance_Day , people over here are yukking it up https://www.freundedescarneval.de/termin/am-11-11-ist-es-wieder-soweit/5522/ . Mitigating factors: 1) "Volksvertrauertag" (national day of mourning) is on this coming Sunday https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkstrauertag . 2) The Berlin Wall fell on 9 November, but since that also happened to have been Kristallnacht (and a whole bunch of other things https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/November_9_in_German_history ) they decided it was more tactful to move German Unity Day from 17 June to 3 October https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Unity_Day .

Although the 11 November start also aligns with St. Martin’s Day, a time historically marking the end of agricultural work for the winter and the beginning of a festive period leading up to the pre-Christmas Advent season, this early November start is more symbolic and a chance to inaugurate the "fifth season" (as Karneval is known in some regions), where Karneval committees and events begin planning and the season’s "Prince" and "Princess" are crowned. This period, however, is relatively quiet since it pauses during Advent and Christmas. Once the new calendar year begins, Karneval comes back to life, with festivities really accelerating after Epiphany (January 6). It reaches a crescendo with events, street parades, and parties in February, especially the days from "Weiberfastnacht" (Women's Carnival Day, Thursday before Ash Wednesday) to "Rosenmontag" (the Monday before Ash Wednesday), just before Lent begins. It's also my observation that Karneval remains a largely Catholic thing.

I once found something interesting online explaining how the history of 11 November as the start of Karneval has very ancient roots: "The number 11 is considered a Jeckenzahl or närrische Zahl (foolish number) and returns in other Carnival institutions like the Elferrat (council of eleven men) or the 11 Maids. Some sources say that the number 11 symbolises the infringement of the 10 Commandments or that it symbolises equality (1+1), meaning that during Carnival normal rules didn't apply and rich and poor, powerful and plebs were equal. So it might have seemed logical to choose 11th of November, 11.11 h as the season's beginning when Rhenian Carnival was revived in the 19th century. The text also mentions that on St. Martin's Day, farm workers were paid and sent back home after the harvesting season; they used to celebrate and children went from house to house to sing and ask for gifts (Martinssingen, still done in some regions) ... Up until the mid-18th century, when the Gregorian calendar was gradually adopted in Europe, November 11 was the Celtic/Pagan celebration of Samhain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samhain . November 11 is also the end of one of the quarterly "terms", marked by a feast day made somewhat necessary anyway because whatever livestock could not be overwintered had to be slaughtered on St. Martin's Day. From medieval times onward, land leases often ran from Martinmas to Martinmas, and Church tax was due that day."

If there are any "Anglo-Saxons" still grumbling about the start of Karneval coinciding with Remembrance/Armistice/Veterans Day https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veterans_Day , there's another 11 November annual event that could be spun as even more disrespectful! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singles%27_Day .

Expand full comment
Anna Maija's avatar

At my children’s nursery here in Scotland some German families introduced the whole nursery to the tradition of St Martin. There was even a borrowed horse (with one of the mums dressed up as a Roman soldier)! It was a lovely event that brought our little community together. My kids are grown up now and I hadn’t thought about this in years until I read your piece. Thanks for sharing!

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts